New Giant Defy’s!

Our Community Forums Bikes & Equipment New Giant Defy’s!

Viewing 4 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #977877
    ShawnoftheDread
    Participant

    I’ve never heard of the Shimano Claris group, but my guess is they’ve renamed the 2300 entry-level group–so a step below Sora.

    Sounds like the cassette has a broad range, and paired with a 50/34 compact crank it would probably serve you well. Both my bikes are 7 x 2 and do okay for my commute. Not perfect though.

    It’s a good price, but you will probably want to upgrade again in a year or two if you go entry-level like this.

    #977878
    DismalScientist
    Participant

    @ebubar 60510 wrote:

    Looking for gearing advice from my pals on here. What say the experts of bike Arlington? 16 speeds too limited for my needs?

    It’s not so much the number of gears as the range. The low gear on that is a 34/32 and the high is a 50/11. That range is almost as big as my touring bike. The low is about 30 gear inches while the high is around 120, which is absolutely huge.

    What gearing you need depends on your riding style and where you ride. I am very rarely out of my large chainring in Arlington. Furthermore, the difference between 8 and 10 cogs is the gap between gears more than the range. Because of this, you may wish to change the cassette at a later date to one with narrower spacing an a larger small cog. (8 speed cassettes are cheap online, about $20.) With a narrower range cassette, you might find that you will use the smaller chainring more.

    Look on Sheldon Brown’s page for gearing information. (http://www.sheldonbrown.org) Certain oldtimers would suggest that larger cassette size (i.e. number of cogs) fosters an “arms race” between component manufacturers and there really isn’t a benefit over 7 cogs.

    #977879
    DismalScientist
    Participant

    One thing to consider with number of cogs is it is cheaper to replace consumable components (chains and cassettes) with fewer number of cogs. $50 retail for a 10 speed chain was quite the shock after I ordered an 8 speed chain online for about $10. This implies a cheaper bike might be somewhat cheaper to maintain.

    #977880
    mstone
    Participant

    Yes, claris is the new 2300 replacement with paddle shift rather than the thumb trigger. Also has more capacity in the rear derailleur than the older model.

Viewing 4 posts - 1 through 4 (of 4 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.