Is cycling the new golf?

Our Community Forums General Discussion Is cycling the new golf?

Viewing 15 posts - 16 through 30 (of 44 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #1011732
    83b
    Participant

    The latest wave of tax-avoidance transactions were dreamed up by some guys out for a ride. My riding buddies (who are mostly tax people) have decided that we need to discuss beer, tacos, and other assorted life stuff less on our rides and instead focus on designing the next big thing in tax shelters. If a couple of dudes from Skadden can do it while meandering about the south of France, I see no reason that we can’t too.

    #1011733
    dplasters
    Participant

    @jrenaut 96467 wrote:

    You’re right, I should take it easy on golfers. Just because I don’t like it doesn’t make it necessarily bad. But the courses do take up a ton of space, cut down all the useful plants and replace them with what’s no doubt non-native grass, and require TONS of upkeep. And they take otherwise pleasant space and make it inaccessible even to the golfers because at any moment there could be a small, hard object moving very quickly at your head.

    The more people we can convince to take up other pastimes, the better off we all are.

    I tried my hardest. But here I go…..

    Unless the other pastime is what? Car racing? We can all agree that is for sure the worst? That’s probably a bad hobby. The Porsche owner who takes his car to VIR would point out that people take their helicopters and airplanes (still kicking around leaded fuel) for joy rides and the Porsche owner can point out that he is responsibly not doing this on public roadways, can cyclists who race / train say the same? Some can, some can’t, some get called pathletes.

    What, preciously, should we do with that space? People are paying to use it right now. People (or local governments) are making money on that land (private courses). Free parks are great, but they cost money (public land/municipal courses). They lose money. Some municipal owned golf courses lose money, but not as much money as they would if they had to upkeep a public park. Are there better things for the environment? Sure. But someone has to pay to maintain them. No free lunches. If so few people use the golf course that it loses too much money and would be better off as a public park I’m in. Awesome, lets do it make it a park. But if it was that easy/straight forward, it already would have been done (could be in the planning? I have no idea which course is the thorn in your side). The reality is probably that the park would cost more and that there isn’t the public support to pay for it. Granted, I live in Fairfax, but there are public parks freaking everywhere. I have seven in my zip code. Two of which could actually fit golf courses on them and I am a 5 minute walk to the metro. Not exactly Clifton.

    Humans have hobbies. Its a great thing. Disparaging a hobby that you don’t enjoy is really easy to do. At some point, we are all doing something that is making the collective “we” worse off. Cycling is no different. Running is cheaper, requires less facilities, requires less non-renewable resources and is a better workout. So the statement “The more people we can convince to take up other pastimes, the better off we all are.” is just as true.

    On the environment / plant side there has been a large push in the last 10 years or so to try and rectify some of the idiocy that occurred between about 1950 and 2000 when as a country, we collectively gave the middle finger to the environment in everything we did. And all of us here wish that there were less insane cyclists to give us a bad name. Please don’t judge all of golf because of a bad / stupid / poorly planned course and please don’t imply that our world is better if we all do the same things. That would be really really dull. There is such a thing an environmentally responsible golf course. I promise you.

    ***** Disclaimer, if the area you live has little to no park space or common use land and an empty golf course and jam packed parks BY ALL MEANS lobby for an alternate use, but that is not even close to the case in many areas and the golf courses are at least providing a revenue source and a green space for people to enjoy their hobby. ******

    #1011737
    jrenaut
    Participant

    You’re right, golf is by far not the worst hobby anyone could have. And some of my distaste for it definitely comes from the fact that I played exactly once and it was (shocking) a disaster.

    But more people cycling has benefits for everyone, even those who don’t cycle. What benefit to society in general would we get from having more people golf?

    #1011739
    hozn
    Participant

    I don’t mind golf courses. Sure, I may personally think golf is a silly sport. I mean, seriously, what other sport has people dressing up in such silly-looking clothing? Thinking … thinking … yeah, I got nothing.

    Golf courses are pretty to look at and it’s nice to see people outside, even if they’re driving the course. Sure, I’d rather have a forest, but dplasters is right; that’s not the alternative here.

    I dunno about the whole business networking aspect that inspired this thread. Golf seems much, much better suited to conversation. Cycling more than two-abreast is hard (on the street) for one thing. Furthermore, if your’e able to hold a conversation for any extended period of time, you’re wasting your time on the bike. Unless it’s winter, I suppose, and your coach has restricted you to a Z2 regiment :)

    #1011740
    Crickey7
    Participant

    @jrenaut 96492 wrote:

    But more people cycling has benefits for everyone, even those who don’t cycle. What benefit to society in general would we get from having more people golf?

    That could be asked of a great many leisure activities, including, I’d argue, masses of people packing hiking trails they drove to reach.

    #1011743
    hozn
    Participant

    @Crickey7 96495 wrote:

    That could be asked of a great many leisure activities, including, I’d argue, masses of people packing hiking trails they drove to reach.

    Sure, or mountain biking on those trails.

    If we take out general benefits of exercise, which arguably can be shared by golfing (assuming you walk), I would suggest that the benefit to society from cycling is pretty limited to cycling for transportation. What greater societal benefit does, e.g., track cycling provide? Mountain biking? Road cycling? Cyclocross?

    #1011745
    jrenaut
    Participant

    @hozn 96498 wrote:

    Sure, or mountain biking on those trails.

    If we take out general benefits of exercise, which arguably can be shared by golfing (assuming you walk), I would suggest that the benefit to society from cycling is pretty limited to cycling for transportation. What greater societal benefit does, e.g., track cycling provide? Mountain biking? Road cycling? Cyclocross?

    And that’s my perspective – the vast majority of my rides are transportation. And I bike because it’s either easier, faster, or makes me happier, or some combination of the three.

    #1011748
    hozn
    Participant

    @jrenaut 96500 wrote:

    And that’s my perspective – the vast majority of my rides are transportation. And I bike because it’s either easier, faster, or makes me happier, or some combination of the three.

    Yeah, I hear you; I think that’s great. I just don’t think that’s the same sort of cycling that we’re talking about when it comes to business networking. However, getting out on a bike may prompt people to do that for non-leisure reasons too — and I agree that would be a positive outcome. But getting people walking a golf course could help them realize they could also walk places when they’re not carrying clubs and that might also be a positive outcome.

    #1011749
    dplasters
    Participant

    @jrenaut 96492 wrote:

    But more people cycling has benefits for everyone, even those who don’t cycle. What benefit to society in general would we get from having more people golf?

    The cycling here is clearly as hobby/socializing only. It doesn’t replace their cars. I agree that using your bicycle to replace or reduce the use of a car can benefit us all. I don’t know how you cycling as a hobby benefits the collective we.

    More jrenauts = better world. More freds = some other hobby is done less (world shrugs).

    Does being a fred lead to bike commuting? Is it a gateway drug? I don’t know. Studies?

    #1011751
    Anonymous
    Guest

    @hozn 96494 wrote:

    I mean, seriously, what other sport has people dressing up in such silly-looking clothing? Thinking … thinking … yeah, I got nothing.

    :confused:
    https://www.google.com/search?q=sumo&tbm=isch&hl=en&gbv=2&oq=&gs_l=
    :p

    (that is what you were trying to think of, right?)

    (right?)

    #1011753
    jrenaut
    Participant

    @dplasters 96505 wrote:

    Does being a fred lead to bike commuting? Is it a gateway drug? I don’t know. Studies?

    I can’t imagine riding your bike as a hobby would lead to LESS bike commuting, but I don’t have any data to back that up. For me, bike commuting led to biking as a hobby and then to biking as my primary mode of transportation. It helps that everywhere I go on a regular basis is less than 4 miles from my house.

    Meanwhile, golfing just led to the nagging fear that the ball I launched awfully close to MD Route 140 in Westminster back in 1996 caused an accident and injured someone.

    #1011754
    lordofthemark
    Participant

    @dplasters 96488 wrote:

    What, preciously, should we do with that space?

    In the case of outer suburban courses they are likely to become low density housing (isn’t that course in Reston, south of the Toll Road, supposed to become townhouses – low density, autocentric style townhouses, not exactly a major contribution to regional urbanist goals) – IMHO might as well stay a golf course. If I were king, I would make courses like that solvent, and in exchange get courses with much more development potential sold – the two I have in mind are the Army Navy course in Arlington, and Carver Langston in DC. Both are in locations where high density mixed use (with some well programmed park space) could advance several public purposes But the former is where the admirals and generals play I guess, and is quite solvent – and the latter while public (so the proceeds of a sale could go to support DC govt purposes) is historically significant IIUC as the first course open to african americans in the region. So neither is going anywhere anytime soon.

    At least we are getting a bike route across Army Navy.

    #1011755
    lordofthemark
    Participant

    @dplasters 96505 wrote:

    The cycling here is clearly as hobby/socializing only. It doesn’t replace their cars. I agree that using your bicycle to replace or reduce the use of a car can benefit us all. I don’t know how you cycling as a hobby benefits the collective we.

    More jrenauts = better world. More freds = some other hobby is done less (world shrugs).

    Does being a fred lead to bike commuting? Is it a gateway drug? I don’t know. Studies?

    Oh I know the answer, call on me!

    More freds means more poltiical support for trails (at a minimum), more support for better in street infra and bike laws (maybe) more visibility to cycling, more drivers who understand something about biking, etc. Critical mass is critical mass – ergo purely recreational cycling (even if they drive their bike to the trail) is still some benefit to transportation cyclists.

    #1011756
    dplasters
    Participant

    *Note to self

    1.) Buy Crabon road bike
    2.) ?????
    3.) Profit!

    I am waiting for Country Clubs to start organizing social bike rides…..

    Clearly we all agree on one thing… biking for transportation is awesome and we need more bike lanes (protected cycleway access path-tracks, for the in crowd).

    Also – I clearly need to organize the first ever official non-official WABA Forum Golf Outing / I’d be excited to get a foursome together.

    #1011758
    dasgeh
    Participant

    @dplasters 96512 wrote:

    I am waiting for Country Clubs to start organizing social bike rides…..

    A ride on the golf cart trails of a golf course could be awesome. If not too hilly, perfect for a KIDICAL MASS. :-)

Viewing 15 posts - 16 through 30 (of 44 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.