Hmm, over 11 million individual bike trips on Capital Bikeshare. No reported serious head injuries. (If there were an epidemic of these cases, Charles Hurt at The Washington Times would be all over this, screaming about how deadly CaBi is in bold type.) Sorry but I’m not seeing the crisis here with bikeshare and helmet use.
I still think it’s smarter for people on faster, private bikes to wear helmets but even then, helmets are only one piece of the safety puzzle. For bikeshare, the data has shown that helmet use ranks very low in importance in maintaining safety. The slower, heavier bikes with upright riding positions and sturdy low center of mass help people to avoid serious accidents in the first place.
As for CaBi being obsolete, I’m not even sure what to make of this. That is really one of the most ridiculous statements I’ve ever heard. Sorry but it needs to be said. Bikeshare allows for one-way trips and trips where cyclists want to avoid the concern of having their bikes stolen while locked up for several hours. It provides an active method of transportation for all the tourists and visitors in DC and Arlington. Bikeshare isn’t intended for racing or for long-distance trips, although some use the bikes for those purposes. Sure, there are also issues with rebalancing. But the operator has set up CaBi bike corrals in downtown DC and in Foggy Bottom on weekday mornings in the warmer months. They can also work on other rebalancing issues in the future. And this has nothing to do with safety.
The heavy, sturdy design of the bikes is a huge positive in terms of safety. This has been proven, not only in the Arlington/DC area but nationwide. With well over 25 million bikeshare trips in the U.S. (and probably closer to 26 or 27 million trips by now), there has still never been a single fatality of a bikeshare user. That is incredible.
Thousands of car drivers die every year in crashes, many of them from head injuries. But there’s no campaign to make them wear helmets. (In a high-speed crash, a helmet would not help that much anyway.)
Not sure I understand Clement’s views on this, at all.