Giro d’Italia!

Our Community Forums General Discussion Giro d’Italia!

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 35 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #1029922
    Bruno Moore
    Participant

    Giro in the morning, switch to California before dinner. I’ve been following the Eurosport feed, complete with GCN’s Matt Stephens in the commentary box and the warnings not to click the “update Flash” popups that periodically obstruct the video.

    Unlike California, where there’s still a point (well, besides team/bike sponsor loyalty) in being a RaboBlancoBelkinLottoJumbo fan, I’ve just taken to rooting for whoever’s doing something cool—lately, someone who looks like they should have gearing restrictions rather than be on the UCI Pro Tour. I mean, Moreno Hofland almost won stage 2, but…uh…um…so, California? Robert Gesink moved up to 6th today? Sagan actually won something for a change? Yeah.

    #1029929
    PeteD
    Participant

    Catching up… Seem to be 2 days behind all week. Should be caught up for Friday. So far, all I have to say is – Domenico Pozzovivo .
    Not so impressed with ToC this year. Vuelta a Catalunya / Vuelta a Andalucia / Tour of Romandie were much better races than the ToC has been.

    –Pete

    #1029931
    PotomacCyclist
    Participant

    Who are the top contenders besides Contador? I haven’t followed any recent updates.

    (I still think the punishment for doping should be much longer than two years. There’s a lot of residual benefit from doping, from being able to train that much harder for extended periods of time. Two years isn’t long enough. If they don’t want to ban someone permanently, then they could choose a longer time period. Four to six years? Seems harsh, but that would be a more effective deterrent. Some would still dope, but they would get hurt worse after they get caught. I know he served his time, and others are probably doping, but I still feel funny watching him win.)

    If he is going all-out in the Giro, I don’t think he will be a top contender at the Tour de France, if he’s even racing it this year. I don’t think anyone can be an overall GC contender in back-to-back Grand Tours. It’s just too difficult, especially against other riders who are only racing in one. (Some cyclists serve as domestiques for one, saving themselves for the other race. That doesn’t count as racing as a GC contender in two Grand Tours.) The only way to recover quickly enough is to dope.

    I see that Nairo Quintana is skipping the Giro to focus on the TdF. I think he has a good shot at improving on his 2nd place finish there in 2013.

    #1029932
    hozn
    Participant

    @PotomacCyclist 115705 wrote:

    I don’t think anyone can be an overall GC contender in back-to-back Grand Tours. It’s just too difficult, especially against other riders who are only racing in one.

    I assume you know this has been done 12 times before? (By 7 riders.). Extremely difficult? Sure. Impossible? Apparently not.

    The Giro this year is indeed off to an awesome start. I have switched to lower cable package, so I just order the Sports Pass for the Spring classics and the Giro and then remove that feature for the rest of the year. The worst part of the coverage is Carlton Kirby (and to a lesser extent Daniel Lloyd). I was also annoyed with Velo for sending an email with the new GC leader yesterday as the subject before I had watched the stage.

    #1029935
    MattAune
    Participant

    @hozn 115707 wrote:

    The worst part of the coverage is Carlton Kirby.

    He is really annoying. He is likely doing the Tour and the Vuelta for Eurosport which means I will have to find another feed.

    I miss David Harmon.

    #1029936
    mstone
    Participant

    @hozn 115707 wrote:

    I assume you know this has been done 12 times before? (By 7 riders.). Extremely difficult? Sure. Impossible? Apparently not.

    I don’t know if anyone could survive taking the amount of drugs you’d need to duplicate that today.

    #1029943
    hozn
    Participant

    All that matters is the relative strength of the riders, so I don’t see any difference there compared to years past.

    Either: (1) the GC contenders are racing clean now and on an even, human-level playing field, or (2) the GC contenders are all doping with stuff the anti-doping controls can’t catch. In any event, I would expect that with the amount of money invested (and at stake) and backroom relationships cultivated here that these teams are on even playing fields, doping or not.

    #1029946
    PotomacCyclist
    Participant

    The key is if there are other top contenders who are rested or not. Neither Chris Froome nor Nairo Quintana are racing in the Giro, as far as I know. That will be huge for their chances in the TdF. That goes a long way toward affecting the short-term relative strength of the riders. Rested or not, racing form or not. Contador just can’t catch up to that level if he races the entire Giro, not without doping.

    It would be different if we were talking about a one-day race. Those riders can recover from that effort in a reasonable amount of time. But a 3-week Grand Tour? That takes too much out of all of them, at least the top GC contenders in the supposed post-doping era. Contador tried to do both a couple years ago, or maybe it was last year. He looked sluggish throughout the TdF. I think other top riders who tried this also had similar results.

    So the difference is if the top contenders are truly clean. If so, I’ll stand by what I said before, that someone who races the Giro hard will not be able to compete at the top level in the TdF that same year, not without a lot of doping. Or unless all of his key competitors get injured or crash out.

    #1029947
    mstone
    Participant

    @hozn 115720 wrote:

    All that matters is the relative strength of the riders, so I don’t see any difference there compared to years past.

    Strength and recovery are two different things; the question is whether the human body can take abuse at that level, recover, and then do it again shortly thereafter. The last guy who managed to win back to back tours is a known doper, and the two before him are suspect. You probably have to go back 30 years to find someone who could win the tour and the giro without modern pharmaceuticals. Can someone do that today, with the levels of peak performance unlocked with current training methods and without the juice? And if someone does juice enough to push to that level of performance, will their body fall apart? As a practical matter, I suppose it’s possible someone might achieve the feat, only to have it stripped in a few years when they develop a new test.

    #1029981
    Powerful Pete
    Participant

    Well that didn’t take long for the entire conversation to get back to doping.

    For back-to-back grand tours you have to also consider the depth of the team – who will be the riders who will support a jersey contender day in and day out in back-to-back tours? That kind of horsepower is not simple to acquire or maintain throughout an entire season. Note some of the turbodiesel engines being used to support a Contador in Italy – Ivan Basso, Roman Kreuziger, Matteo Tosatto and Michael Rogers.

    As for other Giro contenders beyond Contador, I would think the main two (until the inevitable surprises come during the race) are Fabio Aru (young upcoming Italian on Nibali’s Astana who has been made captain for the Giro – current white jersey) and Richie Porte on Sky.

    Good to see Pozzovivo out of the hospital… apparently he remembers nothing of the crash.

    First interview in the hospital (he wants to race the Tour of Switzerland):
    http://video.gazzetta.it/domenico-pozzovivo-incontro-fidanzata-genitori/ec1184b4-f8da-11e4-b50d-9ce10197d64d

    From the Gazzetta website:
    [ATTACH=CONFIG]8600[/ATTACH]

    #1029982
    mstone
    Participant

    @Powerful Pete 115760 wrote:

    Well that didn’t take long for the entire conversation to get back to doping

    Well, that’s the reality of professional cycling for at least the next 40 years. If they clean up today, by then only the old guys will remember this fiasco.

    #1029986
    hozn
    Participant

    @Powerful Pete 115760 wrote:

    For back-to-back grand tours you have to also consider the depth of the team – who will be the riders who will support a jersey contender day in and day out in back-to-back tours? That kind of horsepower is not simple to acquire or maintain throughout an entire season. Note some of the turbodiesel engines being used to support a Contador in Italy – Ivan Basso, Roman Kreuziger, Matteo Tosatto and Michael Rogers.

    That’s a really good point. I don’t know these teams well enough to know who else could feature as supporting cast for the Tour (and who will do both). But yeah these guys don’t win by themselves.

    It’ll be interesting to see whether Contador still has the legs to win even one of these single grand tours. Looks like this thinner Richie Porte is riding really well this year.

    #1029987
    PotomacCyclist
    Participant

    I don’t like bringing up doping because almost every other major pro sports also has serious doping issues. It’s just that they aren’t publicized or for some reason, those sports aren’t as criticized for it. But when the leader in the current races has a very recent doping history, it’s really hard not to mention.

    Same thing with baseball. While Yankees fans might be willing to overlook Alex Rodriguez’s numerous doping issues just because he is hitting well this year, fans of other teams aren’t as willing to overlook it. I hope they are raining down boos on him. Will that hurt his feelings? I guess so. But he has made out like a bandit, winning a 9-figure contract with the help of all that past doping. He was caught and admitted to doping. But then he went back to doping again and tried to interfere with the investigation into that doping. He was suspended last season, but he’s back again and still making millions of dollars, for fraudulent behavior. Baseball players and cyclists will continue to dope if they calculate that it’s worth it in the end. (Football players dope too, only their league doesn’t even test for HGH and that’s reportedly one of their commonly used substances. Compare players from today with stars from the 1970s. It’s almost as if they aren’t even from the same species, because of the size and speed differences. You also have to wonder about all the domestic violence, assault and murder cases with football players. That’s something that we don’t see in cycling on a large scale.) If they are obtaining all that money because of fraud, then why shouldn’t they get punished for it? You can go to jail and lose money for committing certain types of fraud in non-sports contracts. Why not with a sports contract too?

    On other sports sites, I do try to bring up the hypocrisy of people who attack cycling for doping when they overlook or excuse the rampant doping in baseball and football. I don’t normally talk about baseball or football doping here because this is a cycling website.

    If it weren’t Contador in contention for the Giro, I wouldn’t bring this up. As far as I know, Froome and Quintana are clean, so I won’t be talking about doping as much during the TdF.

    I don’t normally like to watch video on smaller computer screens, so I don’t watch much, if any, of the Giro coverage. I’ll check up on the progress occasionally throughout the 3 weeks. But I’ll admit that I don’t follow it nearly as closely as I follow the Tour de France. I guess I have my own limits. It actually gets mentally tiring to follow the TdF for three weeks, trying to find ways to catch some of the broadcasts, either in the mornings or in the evenings or the repeat coverage late at night. I mentioned that it’s tough for a modern rider to compete at a top level in both the Giro and TdF. Likewise, I find it very difficult to follow both the Giro and TdF closely on a daily basis. I think I actually get burned out by the TdF each year. So much so, that I barely have the mental stamina to look at the Vuelta standings in the late summer. I need a better spectator training program…

    #1029996
    PotomacCyclist
    Participant

    From an older post: Chris Froome’s cat doesn’t like Alberto Contador or Tinkoff Saxo:

    [video]https://www.facebook.com/video.php?v=862291693826999[/video]

    #1030023
    PeteD
    Participant

    As for coverage, British Eurosport has the best — Rob Hatch and Matt Stephens are head and shoulders above their normal Eurosport compatriots over on BeIN. Plus the insights of Juan Antonio Flecha are awesome, though I could do without Ashley House.

    Awesome things like: https://eurosport.yahoo.com/video/giro-extra-flecha-rides-giro-133117053.html out of Flecha.

Viewing 15 posts - 1 through 15 (of 35 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.